MOTM vs Dunfermline 22nd September 2018

[Malt]

I thought Buchanan was by far the best player on the pitch.

 

Would agree with IrnBru, I would also be tempted to play Waddle over Kilday

[EanieMeany]

To be fair to Kilday, I don't think he's necessarily calamitous, he's just a bit unconvincing and if there's an alternative we should be looking at him. That said, I wouldn't write off the idea that given a bit of time Kilday could end up forming a good partnership with Buchanan, but in the shorter-term there's just a bit of a ""hrmm...dunno" thing about him.

[TheGoon]

If we’re being ruthless about it, start Waddell, not as if we’ve been getting clean sheets or anything.

[HamCam]

Waddell should be given an opportunity. Chances are if he is only a bit player up to Christmas his loan will not be extended. Not as if Kilday has made himself 'undroppable'.

[BishopBrennan]

Aye, I would have no issue bringing Waddell in for Kilday. I'm starting to fear Kilday won't ever be the same player he was before his injury.

[port-ton]

Kilday looks a bit cumbersome to me but he's actually pretty solid for the most part. His distribution levels are awful though and he always looks up and punts the ball up the pitch even when no one is around him.

 

I'd prefer to have at least one centreback who looks comfortable on the ball, but i haven't seen enough of Waddell to know if he's any better with the ball at his feet.

[mcintyre_gmfc]

Kilday looks a bit cumbersome to me but he's actually pretty solid for the most part. His distribution levels are awful though and he always looks up and punts the ball up the pitch even when no one is around him.

 

I'd prefer to have at least one centreback who looks comfortable on the ball, but i haven't seen enough of Waddell to know if he's any better with the ball at his feet.

Agree with this, his distribution really lets him down.