Jump to content
TheMortonForum.com

Greacen2000

Members
  • Posts

    2474
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    43

Everything posted by Greacen2000

  1. The email very much read to me like a “take your medicine and admit wrongdoing if you want us to come back to the table” type message that was being driven from the EFG side. Seeing the content of the leaked message more or less confirmed this as well as adding the threat of legal action from them into the mix. Reading between the lines it isn’t difficult to guess who the “mct director” might be. The content of the leaked message suggests that “transparent communication” is not this individuals modus operandi which might explain the lack of a signature.
  2. This is exactly my position on the matter. I take full responsibility for the fact I voted for all 3 of the individuals in question, but failure to disclose their hostility toward the sitting mct board, their views on EFG & their intent to work together to further their shared agenda was misleading. Had this information been disclosed I would not have voted for any of them. I take particular issue with Graham, whose actions this week are a direct violation of his stated priorities of transparent communication & togetherness. He needs to go, as do the other 2 if they are indeed in cahoots with him.
  3. Based on the discussions around the EFG deal I believe there were tax implications of selling shares but these could be circumvented by having a share issue instead (which would have the same effect by diluting MCT equity in the club).
  4. Please can everyone who supports the removal of these individuals do their bit and get in touch with any MCT member friends who do not use the forum. I can see a few posts on FB putting the message out but not everyone uses that either. If we are going to get to 100 names within 30 days then it’s important we all do our bit in making sure everyone is informed. For anyone who doesn’t do email, a written request can be posted or handed onto Cappielow.
  5. That might be a more efficient way of doing it - just a question of how best to gather the names etc.
  6. According to MCT articles, it requires the following - 10% would mean approx 100 members need to make the proposal. I would urge anyone who agrees with me to do the following - Email sent to MCT now to communications@mortonclubtogether.co.uk In accordance with article 16(d) I hereby propose that votes take place to remove George Anderson, Graham McLennan & John McMaster from the MCT board. Regards, Sean Fitzharris
  7. As shocking as I find this message to be, I’m glad it has come out as it shows McLennan, McMaster, Anderson & EFGs true colours. All 4 need to get as far away from the club & MCT as possible.
  8. Assuming this originated from Graham McLennan (since it names all other MCT directors with the exception of newly elected Thomas Francis). 2 of his stated “immediate priorities” in the candidate bio were Communication (with an emphasis on transparency), and Togetherness. Yet this message shows him working (apparently in lockstep with 2 other newly elected directors) to try and oust 3 other MCT directors. This is completely at odds with his stated priorities. Personally I would be calling for the resignation/removal of McLennan, McMaster & Anderson before anyone else. Would these guys even have been elected in the first place if they had been fully transparent on their views of the EFG deal, hostility toward existing board members & intent to work together in concert?
  9. Very strange statement. I get that acknowledging the timing of the IA & failures in managing the narrative was maybe something that needed to happen in order to enable moving forward with further discussions, but that being the case there should also have been a similar acknowledgement from EFG on how inappropriate the Xander statement was. Despite my reservations I will keep an open mind until I see what’s on the table
  10. Presumably the players kits for the rest of the season would have the new sponsor (if we manage to find one) put over the top of the Dalrada one too, so I don't see why it would be tinpot to give fans who have bought a kit the option of having the same? Unnecessary cost maybe, but we are probably talking a few hundred quid so not exactly a big risk(and as pedro said there might be scope to factor the cost into the new sponsorship deal). Could also increase the likelihood of selling existing stock of the strips if they look the same as the ones being worn by the players
  11. All O'Hara said was that our position is somewhat unique in that all of the share purchase money was guaranteed to go into the clubs coffers, which wouldn't necessarily be the case if buying shares in another club. That said, it isn't really unique to us - our friends in Govan have long track record of issuing shares like confetti as a means to raise cash from benevolent directors. I don't understand why this has led to a discussion comparing football investment vs non-football investment, or what it has to do with IPOs on multi-billion dollar companies like spaceX?
  12. Great idea - I wouldn't imagine it would cost much to get some patches/transfers printed & keep a stock of them at Smiths & Cappielow to hand out to anyone who has already bought a shirt and wants to iron it on over the top of the Dalrada logo.
  13. Great update addressing many of the questions that have been getting asked recently. Hopefully this will satisfy some of the people who had been holding back on contributing to the FF until these were answered. Also good to see that the cost cutting measures combined with money raised so far seems to have bought us an extra couple of months before we will run out of money. Hopefully some of the discussions currently taking place will come to fruition by then (or we will be relying on reaching the 4th round of the Scottish cup and get drawn away to one of the big teams again) All the better that we have managed to add numbers to the squad while reducing the wage bill. I know the lads we have brought in are rookies, but with an experienced backbone of guys like Longridge, Gillespie, Shug & MOH in the squad then maybe we can get away with it.
  14. Sorry to see Kris go but probably best for all concerned - it gets someone off the wage bill who we hadn’t budgeted to be paying for, and we are replacing him with someone who is coming to is at presumably low/no cost. Also frees up the flat which can be used as digs for the loanees we are bringing in.
  15. That would make sense. It’s a shame it hasn’t worked out for Moore as he looked very promising when he first came in.
  16. Delusions aren’t usually prefaced with words like “if”, “maybe & “perhaps” but ok knock yourself out and file it wherever you like
  17. Yip this crossed my mind too. Maybe they need us more than we need them. Bringing a senior professional club on board would raise their profile quite a bit and could open opportunities for discussions with other clubs. Perhaps they have realised this and are coming back to us with their tail between their legs. If so then I hope we take some new terms of our own to the table too
  18. Major butthurt energy from AR in there along with some absolutely wild takes - spending the entire interview doubling down on Xanders statement despite claiming not to represent EFG - calling out MCT for sharing the draft agreement without EFG approval and calling them “cowards” for sharing the advice of our legal counsel with members in the same breath as blaming MCT for not giving members enough info to make an informed vote. (Let’s also not forget about the numerous times EFG have released information ahead of the agreed timelines; not least their suspiciously timed initial statement on the night the deal was first mentioned to members) - Accusing MCT of starting a disinformation campaign to try and undermine the deal - reiterating Xanders comments regarding Moyes & new players being essential for survival while failing to address the fact that we already have a hole in our budget which EFG money isn’t enough to cover, never mind the additional said costs - criticising GMFC for not being open to getting assistance from Moyes & Cristiano Piccini as they saw EFG involvement in running the club prior to deal approval as “premature”. Strange then that when EFG are so committed to partnership & collaboration that they offered such unfavourable terms when approached for a short term loan - hardly exemplifies the spirit of collaboration. The fact EFG took their ball and ran away as soon as they didn’t get what they wanted also suggests the club were maybe right to be cautious about jumping the gun in getting EFG involved in the running for the club. - suggests that the fighting fund is being used to pay legal fees “for the deal that the same people caused to fail”. I thought that the sum of money & where it was coming from was made pretty clear at the agm? He also said that waiting for administration before doing a fundraiser would be a better approach - claims that members of mct & club leadership & the wider support were reluctant to proceed with the deal due to being overly cautious. From my POV most people were in favour of the deal - the turning point was when the terms were reduced & Xanders statement was read out. Had these 2 things not happened I expect the deal would have been rubber stamped by now. For what it’s worth I believe Alistair when he says he only wants the best for the club. Unfortunately I think he has allowed his judgement to be clouded by his seemingly blind faith in the EFG offering along with the axe he clearly has to grind with MCT & GMFC leadership. Finally - props to Craig Fowler - I’m not a big fan of the guys content but on this occasion he at least did a decent job of cross examining AR on some of his claims. Sure he could have pressed a bit harder on a few points but overall I thought he did a good job so credit where it’s due
  19. You really are having a nightmare here. My last reply (and this one) have fk all to do with the previous discussion I “tapped out of”. Once again you have managed to reply to a post while failing to address the points raised therein. Well done
  20. Are you sure about that? I am not not going to waste my time doing this, but if you were to take an average word count of posts on this thread I am certain yours will be WAY above anyone else’s, mine included. One of the main reasons I have “tapped out” is precisely because you continue responding to simple questions with incoherent rants without addressing any of the points raised. Say what you like about my “boreathon” posts but brevity certainly isn’t your strong point either, champ
  21. I think a portion of it was for shirt sponsorship, but a significant amount was to cover the extensions of contract for certain players. The way it was described to me was that if we extended those players, it would be covered by Dalrada but if we didn’t then the money wouldn’t be available to spend elsewhere. Unfortunately extending them along with Dalrada failing to pay means that their wages are now coming out of what little other budget we had.
  22. I don’t think players would have a basis to terminate their contracts until we fail to pay them (at which point we would be going into points deduction territory). Of course mutually agreed termination could be a possibility if it lets the player pursue opportunities elsewhere and gets a high earner off our wage bill. I assume Brophy is one of our highest earners so it would be good business for us if we could offload him at no cost. Unfortunately with his injury record I don’t see him having a lot of alternatives to choose from.
  23. “reality” only in your own mind. It would have taken a few minutes to make your feelings known, but you didn’t. That’s the reality. I was talking about the disclosure of the soft loans arrangement Instead of answering the fairly simple questions I’ve asked, you’ve spewed out more meandering diatribe. I don’t have any desire to keep this going any longer, but will say once again. I believe that now is absolutely the right time to be trying to raise funds if we are due to run out of money in October - regardless of how we got here & how much faith you may or may not have in club & MCT leadership. You disagree with me - good for you
  24. Totally agree with Dunning - it’s important we don’t do anything to undermine the goodwill that we have seen towards the club in the past week, so any incoming signings need to be announced with transparency around how they are being financed. i wonder if there might be another “Alan Mcmenemy” type arrangement with local businessmen funding a signing?
  25. I don’t think another “point of order” was needed - you are the one who wants shot of Barr, not me. I am just highlighting that your excuse of “there not being enough time” is flaky at best. The fact is that without action, your vacuous whining about Barr is embarrassing. I don't think it was the league cup results that led to this change - I see it more as a combination of the Dalrada situation in addition to the EFG deal going tits up. The statement in May was absolutely needed after an unacceptable season to acknowledge that it wasn't good enough, and was welcomed by most. I am not sure of quite how bad the default situation was at that point, but how exactly would that have changed the message anyway? "we acknowledge that this season was unacceptable and will try to do better but we might not be able to because Dalrada are behind on their payments so we might not have enough money to pay the players"??? If the club believed at the time that Dalrada were going to make good on their commitment, such a statement might have been seen as "jumping the gun", and would likely have had the dual fallout of pissing off our partner & demoralizing the support. Do you think that our current financial situation means that the club should have supported the EFG deal irrespective of the unfavourable terms? Surely if there were concerns about the conditions attached, a failure to disclose them would have raised legitimate questions about “transparency”. We need only look up the road to Govan to see the sort of long term problems that can be caused when financially distressed clubs accept money with too many strings attached. It was actually EFGs statement that triggered this disclosure. Do you think that the club should issue a statement or send a communication to MCT members every time they use a short term loan to bridge cash flow? The term “fan owned not fan run” comes to mind. With the kind of model we have there is always going to be a cut off for where run-the-business decisions crosses into major stuff that needs communicated to & approved by the membership. Determining exactly where this line is drawn is not an exact science. You make the distinction between managing PR with the press vs communicating with the actual owners of the club, yet surely you also realise that as soon as something is communicated to the MCT members, it is effectively in the public domain? To be clear - all concerned could have done a lot better with how this situation was managed & communicated. I just don’t see this as a reason not to support the clubs current fundraising efforts.
×
×
  • Create New...